Whats the difference between the kelley blue book and the nada. Nada numbers come from the auctions and dealer reports. The discrepancy can be attributed to the simple fact that kelley blue book and nada guides use two different methods for calculating a vehicles value. The value will be based on what the dealer will give you for trade or if you sell it privately. The difference between kelley blue book and nada tradein. Research is an important aspect of tradeins as well. Nada also provides data to banks, finance companies, insurance companies, and government agencies. The company is the originator of the term blue book, a book of estimate values of vehicles that dealers and consumer can use when buying and selling cars. Many dealers utilize the kelley blue book guide prices for used vehicles, and dealers and customers negotiate the actual price of a. The main difference between kelley blue book and nada tradein value is the data they use. The kelley blue book values are sometimes lower than the nada values since the nada algorithm calls for all tradeins to be in very clean condition. Nada guides lists prices for fifthwheel trailers, motor homes, camping trailers, truck campers, park models and tow vehicles. The lower nada is usually the more realistic, used when buying.
The kelley blue book used car value is used on sites like autotrader. The reason for this difference is that nada motorcycle guides are. Consumers are apt to run across black book values only when they sell their cars to vehicle resellers. Often recognized as the premier publications in their industry, both guides can be counted on to provide unbiased facts and serve as an essential tool during the car buying process. Since front line might not accurately describe your vehicle, only 5 percent of tradeins or wholesale vehicles are be prepared to adjust your expectations downward from what the nada guide says. Kelly blue book is run by a marketing firm and uses dealer surveys, not actual sales data to guess at car values. The kelley blue book is available both online and in hard copy. The nada website is probably the closest thing to the kelley blue book website when it comes to pricing and value for rvs. Good thing kelley blue book has over 90 years of experience with used car pricing and weve done the analysis for you. Between nada and kbb, the differences vary from month to month. Do you want to know the difference between the kelley blue book and the nada guides.
Black book auto value by sarah brumley the kelley blue book and black book are both price guides for used vehicles, but theyre used in radically different ways. The kelley blue book also lists down various listings and information on standard equipment available on rvs. It gives the opportunity to rate the vehicles condition, and additional options that nada does not allow for. Why is there such a difference between kelly blue book and. The kelley blue book also gathers its data from a number of different sources. However, the blue book also provides figures on new cars and privateparty sales and its rating system on used car conditions is different from the black books. What is the difference between blue book value and nada. Now in adds they will so much off kelley or edmunds. Other guides such as kbb or nada edmunds bases its true market value tmv estimations on actual sales transaction data of similarlyequipped vehicles in the same region. You just simply visit nada guides website and then find and select motorcycles tab in the page. The nadaguides values seem to be consistently lower.
Nada guide, black book and kelley blue book compared autoblog. The nada guides are a comprehensive vehiclelisting website that publishes bluebook type specifications, research material, and pricing information on boats and personal watercraft as well as other types of vehicles. Nada vs kelley blue book nada blue book, nada guide. The main difference between the nada guides and the kelley blue book is their method of computing a vehicles value.
The used car blue book is quite popular and can be a huge help when considering the purchase of a used vehicle. Why is there a difference between the kelley blue book. What do dealers really mean when they refer to the blue book price. While our vehicle value guides are often referred to as the nada blue book, we are not affiliated with kelley blue book. The difference between the kelley blue book and the nada. Of course, the dealer presented me with a deal reflecting the kelly value, and i of course countered with the nada value.
Find pricing and values for power boats, sailboats, personal watercraft, boat trailers and outboard motors. The term blue book is a generic term that has been used for years to describe a periodically issued price list. Therefore, you should never use nada books for real references. Kbb is used more frequently and has been around since 1918, while the black book started in 1955. Nadaguides national appraisal guides and kelley blue book both have a long history devoted to providing consumers and businesses with accurate vehicle. It will direct you to the motorcycle and powersports prices page. The real value of the bike or car is what someone will give you right nowand theres no way to get that number out of a book.
The kelley blue book value of course is significantly lesser of the two because that is the price that the dealer will want to give you for your vehicle. Nadabut, nada is usually used by banks or car dealers to show you an inflated price value. The bottom line, if you like the car, its in good shape, and is comparable to ones in the area, and you like the company youre dealing with, its. Black book and kelley blue book are both usedcar pricing guides. Nada blue book values for used cars, certified preowned cars and more, brought to you by the national automobile dealers association. Car dealers are experts when it comes to deciding a tradein price. I think kbb takes more into consideration than nada does. Counting on nada and kelley blue book to know your. Autoblog explains the difference between the nada guide, black book. When buying a used car, its usually hard to know what a fair price is. The difference in annual premiums may have a definite effect on your general operating expenses, providing you with a little more wiggle room when youre figuring out your monthly budget. Negotiating car trade in value nada blue book, nada. Kelley blue book is a company that was founded in 1926.
You have to consider not just the type of vehicle, but the vehicle condition, mileage and options. Whether youre buying or selling a car, or even just conscious these days, you cant get away from blue book mania. The main difference between kelley blue book and nada tradein value is the data they use kelley blue book gathers information to determine pricing by using information from. The difference between the kelley blue book and the nada guides car price. In 1926, les kelley created the signature kelley blue book. Kbb offers news articles regarding tips for buying and selling vehicles, among other things. I think kbb kelley blue book is best for purchasing the used vehicle.
Kelley blue book and edmunds both offer very good general reference. Many people look at the book as the difinitive authority of worth cash value. How to accurately check for your rv blue book value. Nada book provides listings and information on a range of vehicles, from new vehicles, motorcycles and atvs, classic cars, boats, and mobile homes. The primary difference between kelley blue book automotive values and the nada guides is the basis on which they each arrive at their separate automotive values. They will use a number of resources, namely kelley blue book and nada tradein value, but they mainly rely on their years of experience appraising cars.
Unlike edmunds, however, kelley values generally cater more toward the dealer. Kbb stands for kelley blue book while the full form of nada is national. Differentiate the three by bearing in mind that trade in price indicates what youre going to pay for in an upgrade transaction. When selling, trading or buying a used car, people mainly rely on either of these two resources. The national automobile dealers association website allows you to determine the value for.
What is the difference between black book value and kelly. What is the difference between the tradein value i see on your site and the blue book lending value. Both the kelley blue book and the black book provide tradein and retail values on used cars. Kelley and edmunds are always high in their prices. Instead of kelley blue book, nada guides is also a good choice to value your motorcycle and other vehicles. Bottom line, neither are perfect, but kelley will always rip off the consumer, while nada is considered the best pricing guide available. Learn the private party value, tradein, and suggested retail price of your chosen rv. But if you check nada that price will be right on nadas or real close.
Kelly blue book is the biggest crock of shit ive ever seen. Nada pricing is often higher than kelley blue book since the algorithm has a standard that calls for all tradeins to be in very clean condition. In the most basic sense, kelley places a large amount of emphasis on mileage, condition, features, and popularity, while nada tends to focus on the vehicles wholesale price i. I have noticed some significant price differences between kelley blue book and nadaguides. The nada rv pricing guide is the most accurate one youll find for rv values, however, its not always the easiest one to use. The yellow and blue nada value guide books offer pricing for automobiles, motorcycles, classic cars, boats, recreation vehicles and much, much more. But still you can consult kelley blue book or nada guide nada book for an estimated blue book value and compare the difference in repairs and profit that can be earned after repairs. In 1918, les kelley, a businessman from arkansas, founded a car dealership with no more than three model t fords. Whereas kbb focuses on condition, mileage, popularity, and features, nada places more importance on the cars wholesale price. In the world of used car sales, there are no preset values, so a dealer is free to use whatever sticker price it wants for a used car.
Dealership new scam, nadablue bookblack book value. It can mean the difference between paying the asking price and being able to negotiate down the price by a few hundred dollars or more. Kelley blue book is company that estimates the values of vehicles. Goodwill car donations is here to provide you with all the information. Why is there a difference in kelley blue book and nada. Both are among the most trusted guides in automotive pricing and recognized as the leading publications in the auto industry. Black book and nada are much closer to what the cars would sell for most banks use nada to determine your max. How carmaxs usedcar prices compare to kelley blue book. The wholesale and retail pricing listed in the nada guide seems to be higher in some areas than kelley blue book due to its preset standard that all tradeins be in very clean condition. Finally, a fair purchase price tool provides a snapshot of a vehicles actual selling price from tens of thousands of sale transactions.
The name itself originates from an old registry which lists those of high society and was named the blue book. Semi truck blue book kelley blue book for international trucks if you miss anything it can earn a huge difference in the value amount you produce. In the 1920s, les kelley began to print a list of cars he wished to purchase and how much he was willing to pay for them and then shared this list with bankers and car dealers. Dealers can use both kelly blue book and nada values depending on their preference. The kelley blue book is the most popular usedcar buying guide. Kelley blue book also calculates and provides values for the suggested price of an automobile at automakeraffiliated certified preowned dealerships.
Kelley blue book gathers information to determine pricing by using information from car auctions throughout the country. As a result, you may need to adjust nada prices down. For almost eighty years, nada guides and kelley blue book have served as a guide for establishing price points, helping buyers and sellers fairly negotiate the. The official kelley blue book contains values for cars, trucks and suvs, but not recreational vehicles. At one time blue book value was a used car insiders term like cream puff or cherry, but today the phrase is, er, all over the lot. Consequently, the term blue book has become synonymous with vehicle valuation guides. The only truly accurate value guides are the ones that dealers and banks use.
If you are selling outright nada and kbb average seem to be where it is at, but be warey of you actual market value in your area, as both nada and kbb arent always the best in that case you would introduce edmonds into the equation. They will use a number of resources, namely kelley blue book and nada tradein value, but. For almost eighty years, nada guides and kelley blue book have served as a guide for establishing price points, helping buyers and sellers fairly negotiate the value of new and used cars. On top of using actual sales, we take into account factors such as a vehicles location, color, mileage, condition and options to help deliver a more accurate estimation of.
1175 1435 1183 1530 1308 436 577 688 1525 282 593 206 1181 1047 588 892 1497 1185 1159 788 870 1283 556 1130 603 977 1031 552 1353 866 705 489 165 564 739 959 738 1213 180 77 931 841